Why Present Tense Is the Most Seductive Mistake in Fiction

First-person present tense is the most seductive mistake in contemporary fiction.

Writers discover it in published YA or literary novels and try it themselves. The logic seems sound: “I run down the hallway” feels more immediate than “I ran down the hallway.” More urgent. More cinematic.

What gets lost is narrative distance. Distance is a feature.

When your narrator speaks from some point after the story ended, they can notice irony. They can invest a small detail with weight we don’t understand yet. They can hint at consequences without revealing them. The tension between what the narrator knows and what they’re choosing to tell us is where suspense actually lives.

Present tense strips that away. Your narrator knows only what’s happening right now. Every page is equally urgent—which means no page feels urgent. Urgency without variation is just noise.

The rare exceptions work because the writer understood the trade-off. Most first novels written in present tense would be better in past. Test it: take three pages and rewrite them in past tense. If the story loses nothing, you have your answer.

Want more craft lessons like this — plus personal feedback from me? The Authors Success Bundle Pro gives you access to all 20 Writing Academy courses. Special offer: subscribe now for 70% off — just $29/month