Why Your Subplot Might Be a Sideshow

Most subplots in first novels exist to fill pages.

The writer adds a love interest with a job problem, a best friend going through a breakup, a mystery at the office. Each gets a few scenes, then wraps up. Nothing technically wrong. But the book feels padded. The reader skims.

The subplot is answering a different question than the main plot.

A subplot earns its place when it asks the same core question — just from a different angle.

If your protagonist is learning to stop controlling everything and trust other people, your subplot should put another character through a version of that same test. Maybe she asks for help immediately and things go wrong. Maybe he refuses help even more stubbornly than the protagonist and pays a higher price. Either way, the subplot is doing something the main plot can’t do alone: showing the full range of possible answers to the story’s central question.

The strongest subplots are often inversions. Your protagonist fails a test your subplot character passes — or passes one your subplot character refuses. The contrast makes both journeys mean more.

Here’s the test: take your subplot and ask what question it’s answering. If it’s a different question than your main plot is asking, the subplot is a sideshow. Reframe it or cut it.

Both plots should be circling the same idea from different directions.

Want more craft lessons like this — plus personal feedback from me? The Author’s Success Bundle Pro gives you access to all 20 Writing Academy courses. Special offer: subscribe now for 70% off — just $29/month →