The fastest way to kill a scene is to put a character in a room with no reason to be there. Everybody knows their protagonist wants to solve the murder or win the girl or save the planet. That’s the arc. I’m talking about the reason she walks through that particular door at that particular…
Characters who think too much on the page stop your story cold. A protagonist considers her options, weighs the risks, remembers something from her childhood, and three paragraphs later she still hasn’t opened the door. The reader stopped waiting somewhere around paragraph two. Internal monologue is a trust problem. The writer doesn’t trust the scene…
Most first drafts are full of sentences that tell us what characters are like. “She was generous.” “He was stubborn.” Those sentences do zero work. Character lives in what people do when nobody’s watching. The reader needs to infer the trait from behavior, not receive it pre-labeled. That’s the difference between a character who feels…
Most character arcs end at the climax. That’s where the protagonist demonstrates new behavior under pressure — the big moment. But the scene most writers skip comes right after. I call it the last temptation scene. The moment when the old way of being becomes available again: the old lover shows up one more time,…
Writers confuse argument for conflict. They’re different things with different effects on readers. Argument is one character wanting something while another objects; that’s an obstacle wearing a person’s face. Real conflict is two people who are both completely justified. Take the mother who refuses to let her daughter leave town—she buried her husband eight months…
Your narrator is lying to you. The question is whether it’s on purpose. Every narrator is unreliable to some degree—they can only report what they notice, and what they notice reveals what they believe. The dangerous kind is the narrator who doesn’t know they’re wrong. Here’s the tell: your narrator never questions their own interpretation…
Most memoir drafts have one fatal flaw: only one version of you shows up on the page. There’s the you who lived through the event—confused, scared, hopeful, probably wrong about everything. And there’s the you writing the book, who can see the whole arc from the distance of years. Both need to be on the…
Most YA novels written by adults fail the same way: the teen characters sound like adults trying to remember what being 15 felt like. The problem goes deeper than vocabulary. It’s what the character cares about. Adults frame problems in context—this relationship matters because of my history, this career matters because of my future. Teenagers…
Most romance novels get the obstacle wrong. The external conflict—he’s her boss, she’s leaving town next month, there’s a misunderstanding—is decoration. Readers don’t stay for the obstacle. They stay for the wound. Every compelling romance protagonist carries something that makes love feel dangerous before the story starts. The wound is specific: she watched her mother…
Every confrontation in your manuscript was initiated by someone. If that someone is almost never your protagonist, you have a passive protagonist—and passive protagonists bore readers even in high-stakes plots. Take any 3 scenes. Ask: whose idea was this conflict? If the antagonist keeps knocking on doors and the protagonist keeps answering, the reader will…
The protagonist is running for her life. The world is collapsing. The villain has won. And the reader shrugs. Danger and emotional stakes aren’t the same thing. Plot jeopardy comes free with genre—any thriller has danger, obstacles, conflict. What your reader needs before any of that matters is emotional stakes: what is the protagonist’s deepest…
Most setting descriptions read like the writer paused the story to file a property report. “The room was large, with high ceilings and antique furniture.” We’ve all written it. It tells the reader nothing about the character experiencing it. The fix: filter every detail through your POV character’s emotional state. Whatever she notices should be…
Sign up and get the 25-point checklist my students use — plus the writing resources you choose.