Show Us Who Did It

Watercolor: a door standing ajar in a dark room, light spilling through, no one visible

Mistakes were made. The most famous sentence in American politics, and nobody made them. That is not a flaw in the sentence. It is the sentence working exactly as designed.

The passive voice takes the doer of an action and demotes him, or deletes him entirely. The door was opened. By whom? The sentence doesn’t have to say. Sometimes that’s a virtue. Usually it’s a dodge.

Here is the honest test. Passive construction has exactly two legitimate jobs. The first: the doer is unknown or beside the point. The bridge was built in 1937. Nobody cares which crew poured the concrete. The second: you want the receiver of the action in the spotlight. She was chosen. The moment belongs to her, not the committee, and the passive puts her exactly where the reader is looking.

Every other use deserves suspicion. When you find yourself writing it was felt that or decisions were reached, the sentence is usually hiding something: you haven’t decided who acts, so the action floats free. Readers feel the fog even if they can’t name it. Prose where nothing is anybody’s fault reads like a dream, and not the good kind.

The trick for hunting it in your own pages is silly and it works. Append by zombies to any suspect sentence. The door was opened by zombies. If the sentence accepts the tag, it’s passive. Then ask the two questions that matter: do I know who did this? And does the reader need to?

In fiction the stakes are higher than grammar. Cause is the currency a story spends. A scene where everything was done, was decided, was arranged has no one at the wheel, and the reader’s grip on it loosens. A scene where she slipped the latch and he kicked the door flat has hands in it, and consequences with owners. Character is who did it.

So run the hunt on your manuscript. Search was, were, been, being, and check each one. Some you will keep, the two honest jobs. The rest, put the doer back in the driver’s seat, where the story lives.

This is the craft we teach: https://themeperks.com/writing-classes/